FoxMandal has filed a criminal complaint with Noida police against its former Partners who have allegedly taken away sensitive, proprietary and confidential documents and data from the firm. Lawyers Ravi Bishnoi, Saroj Kumar Jha, Rajan D Gupta and Akshat Pande had left FoxMandal in 2009 to start their own law firm ‘SRGR Law Offices’.
FoxMandal has filed a criminal complaint with Noida police against its former Partners who have allegedly taken away sensitive, proprietary and confidential documents and data from the firm. Lawyers Ravi Bishnoi, Saroj Kumar Jha, Rajan D Gupta and Akshat Pande had left FoxMandal in 2009 to start their own law firm ‘SRGR Law Offices’.
We understand from sources that the complaint has been filed for cheating, defrauding, criminal breach of trust, impersonation and theft of vital data of FoxMandal. The Complaint has been filed under Sections 65 and 66 of the Information Technology Act 2000.
Speaking to Bar & Bench FoxMandal, Delhi, Managing Partner Som Mandal said, “There is no room for double standard persons in legal profession. We have filed complaints against individuals who have been instrumental in stealing our data”.
It is understood that former partners took away the privileged information of the law firm even though they had signed a confidentiality agreement with FoxMandal. Bar & Bench has information that FoxMandal has proof that clearly establishes theft of data and the same has been shown to the Police.
The Police along with the investigation team today reached the premises of SRGR to carry out investigations and have copied all the data from all the computers and laptops. The investigation went on for about 6-7 hours.
Bar & Bench also spoke to SRGR on this issue. Partner Ravi Bishnoi said, “There has been some investigation going on at our office and we have answered all the queries. Also, some of our data has also been copied. This is an absolutely fictitious complaint that has been filed and the same has been filed to create pressure on us as three of our partners including me have filed recovery suits against FoxMandal. Som Mandal has been time and again threatening me that he will file cases against us. We are going ahead with recovery suits”.
Bishnoi further said, “As far as investigation is concerned, we are cooperating with the same. This complaint has been filed with regard to the fact that we have taken some data from FoxMandal. We left FoxMandal exactly about 2 years 10 days back. It is very clear as to what the motive is. He wants us to withdraw the recovery suits. We will go ahead with recovery suits as we have genuine cases. We are now looking at all the criminal options that we have, to file a case against him because this is an unnecessary harassment that he is trying to cause”.
This is the second time in India that lawyers have been accused like this under the Information Technology Act for stealing electronic data. Earlier, Diljeet Titus had filed a criminal complaint against Lex Counsel under the Act.
Comments
Gaggar
December 14, 2011 - 10:11pmMost unfortunate!
Richard Rosen
December 15, 2011 - 12:51amI am glad to see the firm had put in place means to track the removal of the information needed to prosecute. I wonder how common this in the legal industry? I ponder it because I've worked with a number of law firms on installing monitoring software on the end points and my sense is that it's hit or miss - particularly with smaller firms. This type of software keeps a record of files and information sent out of the company by email, Instant Message or to a USB drive. It's particularly important for laptops that leave the network. Reminds me a small firm of 20 that installed it AFTER a partner left and took what he shouldn't have. They knew but had no way to prove it. Too often it's after house has been burgled that the alarm goes in.
Anon
December 15, 2011 - 12:50amBad for the legal profession or industry, whatever you may say!
an
December 15, 2011 - 7:27amlondon houses!
Sera
December 15, 2011 - 11:16amThe dooms day for Fox Mandal and Little has come. [edited] A pot calling a kettle thief. No double standards- What a shame
A Lawyer
December 15, 2011 - 11:14amInteresting! It appears from your report that these guys left FoxMandal in 2009 and have filed recovery suits. What the recovery suits for? In view of the reported facts, what is crucial is the timing of the complaint. Whether before or after the SRGR guys filed recovery suits against FoxMandal?
unknown
December 26, 2011 - 2:12amIts only in India that when a small car hits a big car , its still the fault of the Big car...cant go on like that .. Indian lawyers need to wake up. Cant go on messing with someones data and still shout that you will look at criminal options against someone who exposed you...shame on legal profession for these kind of thieves...right place is behind bars (the real BAR )!!!!!
Add new comment