Technology vs. Austerity: Supreme Court orders 50 Mac Laptops with Windows OS

Bar&Bench News Network

Oct 05, 2009

The Supreme Court has just closed a tender for the purchase of 50 top-of-the-line Apple Macbook Pro laptops as part of their drive to upgrade technology. Each of these laptops cost in excess of Rs. 1,20,000 ($2500), and the tender has been issued by the National Informatics Center, which also runs the Judgment Information System for the Supreme Court, the High Courts and some District courts.

It is being speculated that the system specification for a Windows Operating System (OS) is due to the fact that certain law-related software such as SCC Online are only Windows-compatible.

The tender also mentions Livescribe smartpen and dot paper, an audio application that is intended to keep track of arguments in long-pending cases, and arguments by various counsels that span a number of days.

Ajay Kumar, a tech-savvy law student of Christ University, suggests that the Supreme Court use Open Source software instead of Windows. He points out that government agencies across the world, from Brazil to Iran to France are on a drive to introduce open source software in order to ease the Microsoft/US stranglehold on the software markets. "OpenSource means free updates and no one-time cost of buying the software. This buying of Macbooks and Windows OS is unnecessary expenditure" he states.

Ajay also has issues with the Supreme Court's decision to buy Apple. "Why MacBooks?" he asks. "Have we run out of Indian-made hardware? What is wrong with HCL?" An interesting point, and one that a government currently on an austerity drive would do well to take note of.

 

Add to My Clips Print this Story Email this Story

 

Facebook LinkedIn MySpace Digg Del.icio.us twitter

Comments(3)
  • 1. "What is wrong in government investing in technology? If macbooks can make judges deliver judgments faster- I have no issues. Also, gone are the days when we should say Indian government should buy Indian products. Government should be open to foreign products. This is no longer 1990s. If India wants to be a global leader tomorrow, government needs to think like a global leader. A west bengal mindset will not help India in the long run. ". Vikash, Mumbai
  • 2. "The Supreme Court, either does not understand technology or is being misguided by its advisors at NIC. An apple computer is only good looking hardware and installing Proprietary System on it where the Licensing fee is high and the user has no freedom to copy, modify or share sounds like a stupid step. The judges are mostly not as tech savvy as we would like them to be and installing Microsoft windows on fancy laptops is in no way going to help deliver better or faster judgments.". Anonymous, Delhi
  • 3. "The real question is whether the expensive machines are right use of funds by the court. I don't think so. ". Abu, Dubai
Post Your Comment

Name* :

Location :

Email Id :

Comment * :

Notify me when there is a comment


 

Thank you. Comments are subject to moderation.